Scott Menath (08) had everything a “successful” person would have, but followed God’s direction to serve Christian leaders in his community.

Menath, who graduated from Point Loma Nazarene University in 2008 with a political science degree, found his way there thanks to his family. 

“My cousin got married there, of all places,” Menath said. “And then [one of my] older brothers ended up going to Point Loma because he fell in love with the baseball field and the beautiful views and everything else. And so I went to Point Loma. I had an Air Force RTC scholarship over at San Diego State, but really Point Loma was my main school and I fell in love with campus. I couldn’t imagine going anywhere else, quite frankly.”

Menath was involved with the Department of History & Political Science and enjoyed getting to know people on campus. He especially enjoyed focusing on his studies after years of high school sports and leadership. Unfortunately, graduating in 2008 proved a tough year. 

A PLNU alum with his wife.

“There was really no job market to go around,” he said. “A really tough time to graduate. All through college, I had worked as a bellman at hotels. But after college, I couldn’t even get a call back from any of those places. I applied to hundreds of places here in San Diego and couldn’t find anything. 

“So I ended up back in Lake Tahoe with my dad for a weekend and we went golfing, and I ended up golfing with this gentleman who was with an insurance company. They were based out of Omaha, Nebraska, and I really hit it off with this gentleman. A couple of months later, this guy called me out of the blue and said, ‘Hey, Scott, do you want to move to Nebraska and work for us?’”

Menath was dating his now-wife at the time, and they did long distance while he worked in Nebraska. Two weeks before their wedding, he got a promotion that would require him to relocate to Rhode Island.  

“I got that promotion and said yes to going to Rhode Island without even asking her,” Menath said, but quickly added that “she was thrilled.”

“We were out there for a couple years, and then ultimately came back home,” he said. “I started working on retiring my father and working in his insurance brokerage that he had had for 40 years. We had a pretty good time of growth in the insurance industry, and ultimately retired my dad around 2021. I had pretty much everything that the world would want. I had my in-laws living on my property in Reno. They had their own space. We had more or less our dream house. I didn’t have any debt. We owned our cars and everything else outright. From outside looking in, I had all the comforts that this world truly has to give.”

Menath, however, still felt that something was missing, and he couldn’t figure out why. One day on his way to work, on a typical weekday morning, he had a moment that could only be explained by the Holy Spirit. 

“I was transported to another place for a split second,” he explained. “I could still see the road, and it was like I was daydreaming as I drove. But it felt a lot more vivid and real for me. I felt like I was in a boat being tossed among the waves; it was dark sky above me and dark waves below me. Out in the distance, I saw a figure of someone that I couldn’t even describe, but he had warm, kind eyes, and he pointed and said, ‘Scott, it’s time to get out of the boat. You don’t know how deep the water is going to be, but you need to get out of the boat and follow me.’”

He ended up pulling over and crying for the first time in a long while. He walked into work in a daze and surrendered to whatever God was planning. 

A PLNU alum with his family.

“It was at that moment that things started working faster and faster and faster,” Menath said. “The wheels started moving, the door started shutting on insurance, and the door started opening to working with Christian CEOs and business owners…That’s really where my passions lie.”

The transition was a major one for Menath and his family. Switching careers allowed Menath to follow his vocation, which involves helping Christian business leaders make decisions and be in fellowship together.

“There’s not a lot of people who truly understand the weight of the decision-making that’s on their shoulders,” he said. “They’re lonely in the decision-making process, and few people understand. With being a CEO, most of my employees would have made the same decisions at the same time that I would have made them. But you can’t openly discuss all those issues just out and out in a public forum. So that’s when I discovered C12.”

C12 is an organization that exists to bring Christian CEOs and business leaders around the same table, where they can gather in fellowship, workshop problems, and receive coaching. Joining C12 was a decision that would, by most accounts, not make sense. Menath had his dream house, a stable career, and financial stability. But faith, for him, looked like taking a chance. 

“It felt like I was stepping into a fog bank where I couldn’t see my feet or couldn’t see my hand in front of me. But every time my foot hit the floor, I could feel the solidness, and I could feel that God was leading.”

Menath’s family were fully behind him as well, ready to step out into a new adventure.

“[My wife] has been an absolute rock. She went to Point Loma, class of 2008 as well. She was 100% behind me. And I’ve got two boys, and I think they were excited for the adventure as well. The whole family was in support. It was more the rest of the world that was like, ‘What are you doing?’”

“It felt like I was stepping into a fog bank where I couldn’t see my feet or couldn’t see my hand in front of me. But every time my foot hit the floor, I could feel the solidness, and I could feel that God was leading.”

Menath most enjoys how he gets to help Christian business leaders live out their own vocations, focusing particularly on the workplace. 

“God calls us to all sorts of different places in all sorts of vocations,” he explained. “Of the 52 parables, in 45 of those Jesus talked about local trades, used language of the workplace, and he was preaching in the marketplace more than anywhere else. When I die someday and ultimately come face to face with my Lord and Savior, I know He’s going to say, ‘Yeah, your Sundays were great. You were a wonderful Christian on the weekends, but how were you as a Christian on a Tuesday morning going through a contract negotiation, or when an employee had a major issue?’ So, how do we truly connect our Sundays to Mondays?”

For those still discerning their vocations, or considering a major life change, Menath advises that they surround themselves with wise counsel, stay in prayer, and stay in the Word.

“Once you have clarity that that decision is the way that you need to go, you need to just get out of the boat,” he said. “You jump with two feet straight into it. Don’t look back. Don’t turn back. It is not our business to succeed. It is our business to be faithful to the Lord, and He will make straight our paths.”

A PLNU alum with his family.
Emma McCoy graduated from PLNU in 2023 with a BA in Literature English Education and a minor in writing. She received her M.A in Writing in 2025 from PLNU and spends her time enjoying the written word, kayaking, and petting her dogs.